Miracle Tradition, Rhetoric, and the Synoptic Problem
by D.G. Reid
This study examines the relative plausibility of three contemporary synoptic gospel source-critical hypotheses, namely the Two-Document Hypothesis (2DH), the Two-Gospel Hypothesis (2GH), and the Farrer Hypothesis (FH). Specific attention is paid to the implied redaction of the Gospel miracle traditions, which are evaluated through the lens of first-century Greco-Roman biographical and narrative rhetorical conventions. The influence of such conventions is first demonstrated in the known adaptations of two first-century writers, namely Josephus and Plutarch. The same conventions are then used to assess the relative redactional plausibility of the three synoptic hypotheses, first in relation to the implied order and selection of miracle traditions, then in relation to narrative adaptations in three specific miracle pericopes.
This study examines the relative plausibility of three contemporary synoptic gospel source-critical hypotheses, namely the Two-Document Hypothesis (2DH), the Two-Gospel Hypothesis (2GH), and the Farrer Hypothesis (FH). Specific attention is paid to the implied redaction of the Gospel miracle traditions, which are evaluated through the lens of first-century Greco-Roman biographical and narrative rhetorical conventions. The influence of such conventions is first demonstrated in the known adaptations of two first-century writers, namely Josephus and Plutarch. The same conventions are then used to assess the relative redactional plausibility of the three synoptic hypotheses, first in relation to the implied order and selection of miracle traditions, then in relation to narrative adaptations in three specific miracle pericopes. While the cumulative evidence clearly points to the greater plausibility of the Markan Priority hypotheses over against the 2GH, neither the 2DH nor FH was demonstrably more plausible than the other.
- By (author) DG Reid
Other Titles in this Series
Die sieben Sendschreiben Apk 2-3
Studien zu ihrer Entstehung und ihrem Verhaltnis zum apokalyptischen Hauptteil Apk 4-22
Volume 39
Ephesische Enthullungen 1
Fruhe Christen in einer antiken Grossstadt. Zugleich ein Beitrag zur Frage nach den Kontexten der Johannesapokalypse
Volume 6
The Spirit Helps our Weakness
Rom 8:26a in Light of Paul's Missiological Purpose for Writing the Letter to the Romans
Volume 36
Constructing Religious Identities during the Second Temple Period / Construction des identites religieuses a l’epoque du Second Temple
Festschrift for Jean Duhaime on the Occasion of his 86th birthday
Volume 24
The Vocabulary of Luke
An Alphabetical Presentation and a Survey of Characteristic and Noteworthy Words and Word Groups in Luke's Gospel
Volume 10
L’ange et la sueur de sang (Lc 22,43-44) ou comment on pourraitbien encore écrire l’histoire
Volume 7
Der erste Petrusbrief und die johanneischen Schriften
Versuch einer traditionsgeschichtlichen Verhältnisbestimmung
Volume 46
Theologizing in the Corinthian Conflict
Studies in the Exegesis and Theology of 2 Corinthians
Volume 16
Studien zu Einleitungsfragen und zur Theologie und Exegese des Neuen Testaments
Gesammelte Aufsatze von Peter Dschulnigg
Volume 9
Similar Books
Athanasius of Alexandria, Epistula ad episcopos Aegypti et Libyae
Old Slavonic Version and English Translation
Volume 261
Contesting Labeled Identities
The Sociology of Gentilics in Biblical and Northwest Semitic Literature
Cyril of Alexandria’s Christological Exegesis
Explorations of Partitive Exegesis in the Dialogues on the Trinity
Volume 70
Epiphanies of the Divine in the Septuagint and the New Testament
Fifth International Symposium of the Corpus Judaeo-Hellenisticum Novi Testamenti (CJHNT), 14-17 May 2015, Nottingham
Extracanonical Traditions and the Holy Land
Texts, Rituals, and Material Culture in Late Antique Palestine
From Joseph to Jesus
The Joseph Narrative as a Compositional Template from Old Greek Esther to the Gospel of Luke
Volume 125
Nicholas of Lyra’s Commentaries on the Gospels of Matthew and Luke
Franciscan Exegesis in a Time of Crisis
Paradise Lost in Transmission
The Return to Eden in the Apocalypse of Peter within Its Ethiopic and Early Christian Contexts
Punning in Odd or Elegant Constructions in Jeremiah
The Convergence of Linguistics, Rhetoric, and Textuality in the Hebrew Text of Jeremiah
Reformed Covenantal Eudaimonism
Wilhelmus à Brakel (1635–1711) on Highest Good, Virtue, and Law
Volume 87
