The Law of Proof in Early Modern Equity.

By (author) Michael R. T. Macnair

Extent: 322 pages

Publisher: Duncker & Humblot

Subjects: Law

Series: Comparative Studies in Continental and Anglo-American Legal History

Series volume number: 20

Language: English

Paperback (Published)

(February 1999)

ISBN: 9783428091980

6.18 x 9.17 inches

Price: $160.00

On back order

Add to cart -
back order

Synopsis
Contributing Authors

This volume is a systematic study of the rules of proof in English Courts of Equity between the later sixteenth and the early eighteenth century. In this period the proof practices of the Courts of Equity were controversial, as contemporary lawyers saw them as linked to the Civil Law, and some perceived a threat to the Common Law tradition. The reality of this linkage and threat has continued to be controversial among historians. In addition, this period saw the early stages of the development of the Common Law of Evidence, which in modern law is a striking divergence from Civil Law systems. The origins of the law of evidence have traditionally been linked to the need for judges to control the jury, but this view has been subject to several recent critiques. The Courts of Equity did not generally use jury trial. This study considers Equity proof rules in their relationships to contemporary Civil and Canon Law proof conceptions, medieval Common Law rules governing proof of facts, and early Common Law evidence rules. It concludes that Equity courts operated a variant of civilian proof concepts, and mediated an influence of these concepts on the origins of the Common Law of Evidence. These findings cast a new light on the debates on these origins, and on the relationship between the Common Law and Civil Law traditions in early modern England.

By (author) Michael R. T. Macnair

Other Titles in this Series

Ratio decidendi.

Guiding Principles of Judicial Decisions. Vol. 1: Case Law.

Edited by W. Hamilton Bryson Edited by Serge Dauchy

Limitation and Prescription.

A Comparative Legal History.

Volume 33

Edited by Harry Dondorp Edited by David Ibbetson Edited by Eltjo J. H. Schrage

The Reception of Continental Ideas in the Common Law World 1820–1920.

Volume 13

Edited by Mathias Reimann

Seigneurial Jurisdiction.

Volume 21

Edited by Lloyd Bonfield

Englische und kontinentale Rechtsgeschichte: ein Forschungsprojekt.

Volume 1

Edited by Helmut Coing Edited by Knut Wolfgang Nörr

Historische Schule und Common Law.

Die deutsche Rechtswissenschaft des 19. Jahrhunderts im amerikanischen Rechtsdenken.

Volume 14

By (author) Mathias Reimann

Negligence.

The Comparative Legal History of the Law of Torts.

Volume 22

Edited by Eltjo J. H. Schrage

The Courts and the Development of Commercial Law.

Volume 2

Edited by Vito Piergiovanni

Marriage, Property and Succession.

Volume 10

Edited by Lloyd Bonfield

The Laws’ Many Bodies.

Studies in Legal Hybridity and Jurisdictional Complexity, c1600–1900.

Volume 32

Edited by Seán Patrick Donlan Edited by Dirk Heirbaut

Rechtsfähige Stiftung und Charitable Corporation.

Überlegungen zur Reform des deutschen Stiftungsrechts auf der Grundlage einer historisch-rechtsvergleichenden Untersuchung der Entstehung des modernen deutschen und amerikanischen Stiftungsmodells.

Volume 23

By (author) Andreas Richter

The Trial Jury in England, France, Germany 1700–1900.

Volume 4

Edited by Antonio Padoa Schioppa

Die deutsche Wissenschaft vom englischen Staatsrecht.

Ein Beitrag zur Rezeptions- und Wissenschaftsgeschichte 1748–1914.

Volume 16

By (author) Wolfgang Pöggeler

Ratio decidendi.

Guiding Principles of Judicial Decisions. Vol. 2: 'Foreign' Law.

Edited by Serge Dauchy Edited by W. Hamilton Bryson Edited by Matthew C. Mirow

The Records of the Medieval Ecclesiastical Courts.

Part II: England. Reports of the Working Group on Church Court Records.

Volume 7

Edited by Charles Donahue, Jr.

The Civilian Writers of Doctors’ Commons, London.

Three Centuries of Juristic Innovation in Comparative, Commercial and International Law.

Volume 3

By (author) Daniel R. Coquillette

From the Judge’s ›Arbitrium‹ to the Legality Principle.

Legislation as a Source of Law in Criminal Trials.

Volume 31

Edited by Georges Martyn Edited by Anthony Musson Edited by Heikki Pihlajamäki

Actio Pauliana und fraudulent conveyances.

Zur Rezeption kontinentalen Gläubigeranfechtungsrechts in England.

Volume 29

By (author) Constantin Willems

Case Law in the Making.

The Techniques and Methods of Judicial Records and Law Reports. Vol. 1: Essays.

Edited by Alain Wijffels

The Records of the Medieval Ecclesiastical Courts.

Part I: The Continent. Reports of the Working Group on Church Court Records.

Volume 6

Edited by Charles Donahue, Jr.

Ars Persuasionis: Entre doute et certitude.

Volume 30

Edited by Bernard Durand

Case Law in the Making.

The Techniques and Methods of Judicial Records and Law Reports. Vol. 2: Documents.

Edited by Alain Wijffels

Judicial Records, Law Reports, and the Growth of Case Law.

Volume 5

Edited by John H. Baker

Ius quaesitum tertio.

Volume 26

Edited by Eltjo J. H. Schrage

Anglo-American Law and Canon Law.

Canonical Roots of the Common Law Tradition.

Volume 18

By (author) Javier Martínez-Torrón

Towards a General Law of Contract.

Volume 8

Edited by John Barton

The Law of Presumptions: Essays in Comparative Legal History.

Volume 27

Edited by Richard H. Helmholz Edited by W. David H. Sellar

Itinera Fiduciae.

Trust and Treuhand in Historical Perspective.

Volume 19

Edited by Richard Helmholz Edited by Reinhard Zimmermann

Studien zur Einwirkung der Industrialisierung auf das Recht.

Volume 9

Edited by Helmut Coing

Within a Reasonable Time: The History of Due and Undue Delay in Civil Litigation.

Volume 28

Edited by C. H. van Rhee

Similar Books

East Meets West: Justice, Law, and Politics

The 13th Kobe Lecture and the 2nd IVR Japan International Conference, Chiba, September 2023

Edited by Makoto Usami Edited by Hidehiko Adachi

False Friends in Comparative Law

Advantages and Risks of Legal Transplants in Civil Law – the Polish-German Perspective

Contributions by Wojciech Bańczyk Contributions by Magdalena Bławat Contributions by Witold Borysiak Contributions by Przemysław…

Global Legal Pluralism and Rights of Nature

Volume 151

Edited by Daniel Bonilla Maldonado Edited by Ralf Michaels

Law, Economics, and Inequalities in the Welfare State

Proceedings of the Special Workshops held at the 31st World Congress of the International Association for Philosophy of Law and Social Philosophy in Seoul, Republic of Korea, 2024

Edited by Arnulfo Daniel Mateos Durán Edited by Patricia Mindus Edited by Alessio Sardo

Legal Pluralism and the Tajik Experience of Xinjiang

Between Custom and the Chinese State: An Ethnographic Perspective

By (author) Amier Saidula

Liturgia semper reformanda

Adaptations and accommodations in the liturgy in light of canon 838 of the Code of Canon Law

By (author) Marcin Kołodziej Series edited by Rajmund Pietkiewicz Series edited by Piotr Burgoński

Model EU and Pattern OHADA?

Perspectives of a Mutual Influence in Commercial Law

Edited by Peter Jung

Océans

Volume 43

Volume editor Odile Delfour Series edited by Odile Delfour Volume editor Frantz Mynard Series edited…

The EPPO/OLAF Compendium of National Procedures: Estonia

Desktop codes on the procedural law of the Member States with annotations by national experts

By (author) Pierre Hauck By (author) Jan-Martin Schneider

The EPPO/OLAF Compendium of National Procedures: Greece

Desktop codes on the procedural law of the Member States with annotations by national experts

By (author) Pierre Hauck By (author) Jan-Martin Schneider

The EPPO/OLAF Compendium of National Procedures: Italy

Desktop codes on the procedural law of the Member States with annotations by national experts

By (author) Pierre Hauck By (author) Jan-Martin Schneider

The Right to Regulate of Developing Countries in International Investment Law

A Contextual Approach to International Investment Agreements

Volume 11

By (author) Thomas Dromgool

Law and Literature

An Interdisciplinary Exploration of Medieval Texts

Volume 1

Edited by Ignazio Alessi Edited by Gavino Scala

The Polish Code of Obligations of 1933

Historical Roots and Comparative Context

Edited by Tomasz Giaro

(Bloß) symbolische Rechtsetzung

Eine interdisziplinäre Untersuchung der deutschen Glücksspielregulierung auf ihre funktionelle und symbolische Wirkung

By (author) Robin Anstötz

Active Space Debris Removal

Rechte und Pflichten der Staaten im Kontext der aktiven Weltraumabfallbeseitigung

Volume 268

By (author) Michael Vincent Gründer

Algorithmische Kollusion auf hybriden Handelsplattformen

By (author) Svenja Huemer

Annäherungen an das japanische Recht

Festschrift für Heinrich Menkhaus zum 70. Geburtstag

Volume 245

Edited by Heike Alps Edited by Deniz Günal Edited by Sandra Schuh

Artikel 102 AEUV und Nachhaltigkeit

Eine juristisch-ökonomische Analyse der Berücksichtigungsfähigkeit von Nachhaltigkeitsbelangen im Rahmen der Missbrauchsaufsicht

By (author) Jule Halbach

Ausforschung und Rechtsdurchsetzung im Unionsprivatrecht

Herleitung und Ausgestaltung eines allgemeinen unionsrechtlichen Informationsrechts

By (author) Matteo Bruno Fontana

Ausnahme und Vielfalt im römischen Recht

Contributions by Pierangelo Buongiorno Contributions by Arnaud Besson Contributions by Eva Jakab Contributions by Salvatore…

Bedrohte Freiheit

Universitäre Bildung seit Corona

Contributions by Mathias Brodkorb Contributions by Michael Krüger Contributions by Oliver Lepsius Contributions by Silvia…

Beiträge zur Rechtsgeschichte Österreichs, 16. Jahrgang, Heft 1/2026

Edited by Thomas Olechowski

Betriebsrat für Dummies

By (author) Margarete Graf By (author) Sigrid Britschgi

Codex. Vol. 7, 2026

Giornale romanistico di studi giuridici, politici e sociali

Volume 7

Edited by Oliviero Diliberto Edited by Claudia Giuffrida Edited by Meiling Huang Edited by Orazio…

Compliance-Organisation von Institutskonzernen im Schnittfeld von Gesellschaftskonzern- und Finanzmarktrecht

Volume 294

By (author) Christoph von Thaden

Credit Default Swap-Aktivismus

Eine ökonomische Analyse und rechtliche Bewertung der Einflussnahme von Credit Default Swap-Investoren auf Unternehmen

By (author) Julian Franke

Das Burgenland als rechtlicher Zwischenraum

Volume 235

Edited by Martin Löhnig Edited by Kamila Staudigl-Ciechowicz

Das Gleichlaufprinzip im Europäischen Kollisions- und Zuständigkeitsrecht

By (author) Vincent Stangenberg

Das Recht auf Bildung in Deutschland seit 1919

Volume 237

By (author) Romy Roomiany

Das rechtliche Erbe Österreichs im polnischen Verwaltungsverfahren

Zum 100-jährigen Jubiläum des Allgemeinen Verwaltungsverfahrensgesetzes (AVG 1925–2025)

Contributions by Irena Lipowicz Contributions by Bernd Wieser Contributions by Matthias Lukan Contributions by Wojciech…

Das Rheinische Recht

Neue Perspektiven auf die Geschichte des französischen Rechts an Rhein und Mosel, ca. 1750 bis 1900

Contributions by Gregor Albers Contributions by Kristin Boosfeld Contributions by Franz Dorn Contributions by Carsten…

Das Rückschrittsverbot als Instrument Europäischen Werteschutzes

Schutz unionaler Werte im Spannungsfeld nationalstaatlichen Pluralismus

By (author) Lena Sophie Kaiser

Das Spannungsverhältnis von Freiwilligkeit und Zwang

Eine grenzüberschreitende Untersuchung obligatorischer Schiedsverfahren

Volume 248

By (author) Laura Kähler

Datengetriebenes Eventmanagement

Eventdaten verstehen, skalieren, nutzen – ein Playbook

By (author) Jens Kuntzemüller

Datenschutz, Grundeigentum und agrarische Bodendaten

By (author) Leonard Nicolay

Der Einsatz Künstlicher Intelligenz beim Erlass polizeilicher Platzverweisungen

Zulässigkeit eines Ermessensverwaltungsaktes durch Künstliche Intelligenz im Lichte des allgemeinen Verwaltungsrechts und des Grundgesetzes am Beispiel der polizeilichen Platzverweisung

Volume 37

By (author) Lynn Schaefer