Property Rights in the Late Medieval Discussion on Franciscan Poverty

by V. Makinen

Extent: 224 pages

Publisher: Peeters Publishers

Subjects: Medieval Studies, Philosophy

Series: Recherches de Théologie et Philosophie Médiévales - Bibliotheca

Series volume number: 3

Language: English

(Paperback) (Published)

(October 2001)

ISBN: 9789042909403

Price: $50.00

Out of stock

Add to cart -
back order

Synopsis
Contributing Authors

Property Rights in the Late Medieval Discussion on Franciscan Poverty contributes to our understanding of the history of the concept of individual natural rights by tracing the controversies surrounding the Franciscan ideal of absolute poverty from the 1250s to the 1320s. Virpi Makinen, Th.D., analyzes the complex legal, moral, and theological arguments for and against the Franciscan ideal of giving up all rights over property – an ideal that the Franciscans argued was in perfect imitation of Christ and the Apostles. Makinen pays particular attention to the concepts of rights, especially to the distinctions between dominion (dominium), right (ius) and factual use (usus facti). She discusses the arguments made by both the defenders of the Franciscan claim of apostolic poverty (Bonaventure and Bonagratia of Bergamo) and the attackers, most of whom were secular clerics (such as William of Saint-Amour, Gerard of Abbeville, Henry of Ghent, and Godfrey of Fontaines). Makinen then analyzes the support the Order received from the papacy, and how this support was undermined by Pope John XXII’s vehement attack on the Franciscans in the 1320s. The book shows how the debate concerning Franciscan poverty gave rise to a new language of rights, which paved the way to the idea of individual natural rights.

By (author) V Makinen

Other Titles in this Series

George Amiroutzes: The Philosopher and His Tractates

Volume 12

By (author) J. Monfasani

Das Problem der Willensschwäche in der mittelalterlichen Philosophie/ The Problem of Weakness of Will in Medieval Philosophy

Volume 8

Edited by T. Hoffmann Edited by J. Müller Edited by M. Perkams

Penser avec Avicenne

De l'héritage grec à la réception latine, en hommage à Jules Janssens

Volume 20

Edited by D. De Smet Edited by M. Sebti

The Cistercian Hermann Zoest’s Treatise on Leavened and Unleavened Bread (‘De fermento et azimo’)

Oecumenism, Exegesis, and Science at the Council of Basel

Volume 21

Edited by P. Nothaft Edited by C. Schabel

The ‘Lectura Thomasina’ in Its Context

Philosophical and Theological Issues

Volume 18

edited by A. Speer and A. Colli

Studies in Later Medieval Intellectual History in Honor of William J. Courtenay

Volume 14

Edited by W.O. Duba Edited by R.L. Friedman Edited by C. Schabel

Lateinische Rivalen in Konstantinopel

Anselm von Havelberg und Hugo Eterianus

Volume 15

by G. Kapriev

Modern Views of Medieval Logic

Volume 16

edited by S.L. Uckelman, C. Rode, B. Loewe and C. Kann

Nikolas Kabasilas

Ein Weg zu einer Synthese der Traditionen

Volume 13

by M. Dordevic

Durand of Saint-Pourcain and His Sentences Commentary

Historical, Philosophical, and Theological Issues

Volume 9

edited by A. Speer, F. Retucci, T. Jeschke and G. Guldentops

Greeks, Latins, and Intellectual History 1204-1500

Volume 11

Edited by M. Hinterberger Edited by C. Schabel

Similar Books

Bias and the Middle Way

How to stop Absolutizing our Conditioned Assumptions

By (author) Robert M. Ellis

Charting the Future of Historical Humanities

Volume 16

edited by Pieter d'Hoine, Daria Kohler and Wim Decock

Chuck, Appearance and Reality

Everyday Philosophy in a TV Spy Comedy

By (author) Kelly Dean Jolley

Coins and Money in the Middle Ages

Studies in Honor of Alan Stahl

Volume 50

Edited by Merle Eisenberg Edited by Lee Mordechai Edited by David Yoon

Defining Comedy

Reflections on the Usual Suspects

By (author) David Ellis

Episcopal Power and Patronage in Medieval Europe, 998-1503

Volume 45

edited by Evan Gatti and Angelo Silvestri

Fairy Encounters in Medieval England

Landscape, Folklore and the Supernatural

By (author) Jeremy Harte

Fifty Years of Insight

Bernard Lonergan's Contribution to Theology and Philosophy

edited by Neil Ormerod, Robin Koning and David Braithwaite

Funeral Rites of the Yotvingians

Excavations from a Cemetery in North-eastern Poland

Volume 14

By (author) Ludwika Jończyk

Going through Hell

A Guide to Dante’s Inferno for the Intrepid Traveller

By (author) Robert-Louis Abrahamson

Greatest Debate

The 1409 Arts Quodlibet at the University of Prague

Volume 1

Edited by Luigi Campi Edited by Ota Pavlíček

Innovation and Medieval Communities

The Circulation of Ideas and Practices in and out of the Town (1200-1500)

Volume 63

Edited by Elodie Lecuppre-Desjardin Edited by Nils Bock Edited by Élodie Lecuppre-Desjardin

Lutheran Middle Ages

The Survival of Medieval Art in Lutheran Churches in Germany

By (author) Justin E. A. Kroesen By (author) Justin Kroesen

Medieval Yeghegis, Armenia

History, Archaeology, Society. Local Multiplicities and Global Connections of a Rural Centre on the Silk Road(s)

Edited by Zaroui Pogossian Edited by Michele Nucciotti

On Human Ambiguity

Writings on Religion and Subjectivity

By (author) Arne Grøn Edited by William Mathorne Edited by Bjarke Mørkøre Stigel Hansen

Pastoral Works

Priests, Books, and Compilatory Practices in the Carolingian Period

Volume 64

by Bastiaan Waagmeester

Paths to the Past

On the Conception of Medieval Architecture and Other Essays

Volume 13

by Wolfgang Schenkluhn

Power and Women in Southeast and Central Europe in Late Medieval and Early Modern Period (1300-1600)

Volume 10

Edited by Melina Rokai

Sextus Empiricus on Fallacies and Expert Knowledge

by Johanna Helene Schmitt

Speculative Cartographies

Material Ecopoetics and Weird Mappings

Volume 9

By (author) Grzegorz Czemiel

Tabule Resolute

The Central European Type of Alfonsine Tables

Volume 4

By (author) Petr Hadrava By (author) Alena Hadravová

The Gothic Cathedral in Cracow and the European Architecture Around the Year 1300

Volume 15

by Jakub Adamski and Piotr Pajor

The Occupatio by Odo of Cluny

Edition, Translation, and Commentary

Volume 18

By (author) Christopher A Jones By (author) Christopher A. Jones

The Old English Poet as Reader

Volume 7

by Daniel Thomas

The Venetian Dukes in Early- and High-Medieval Historical Texts: A Reader

A Reader

Edited and translated by Luigi Andrea Berto

Theologia modernorum

Research on Robert Holcot's Theological Questions

Volume 9

Edited by Pascale Bermon Edited by Christophe Grellard Edited by Pascale Bermon

Time, Space, and Narrative in Medieval Icelandic Literature

Volume 16

edited by Ben Allport and Alison Finlay

Transitive Media [Philosophy]

Think(er)ing Technologies in Real-Time

By (author) Wolfgang Ernst

Tributes to Elizabeth Sears

Activating the Eye and Mind

Volume 13

Edited by Achim Timmermann Edited by Heidi Gearhart

Women and Goddesses in Old Norse Mythology and Folklore

Volume 15

edited by Tommy Kuusela and Ingunn Asdisardottir

Women in Late Antiquity and the Early Middle Ages

Studies from Western Europe and North Africa

Volume 44

Edited by Maijastina Kahlos Edited by Éric Fournier

Das unersetzbare Selbst

Der Mensch im Zeitalter der Kunstlichen Intelligenz

by Emil Angehrn

Hermeneutisches Wissen

Essays nach Gadamer

By (author) Tobias Keiling

Jan Schröder: Recht als Wissenschaft

Ein Kommentar

Edited by Marietta Auer Edited by Ralf Seinecke Edited by Stefan Vogenauer

Les Mondes du théâtre

Farces, sotties et autres spectacles XVe -XVIe siècles

By (author) Jelle Koopmans

Los oficios de los diplomas latinos de la Cataluna altomedieval

Estudio de las innovaciones lexicas: XI Premio Internacional de Tesis Doctorales Fundacion Ana Maria Aldama Roy de Estudios Latinos

Volume 106

by Carlos Prieto Espinosa

Natürliche Theologie

Beiträge zu ihrer Problemgeschichte und zur Frage ihrer gegenwärtigen Relevanz

Edited by Markus Höfner Edited by Matthias D. Wüthrich

Seiltanzer

Reflexionen uber eine Daseinsmetapher

by Gunnar Schmidt

Sitten zwischen Moralphilosophie und Politischer Okonomie am Ende des 18. Jahrhunderts

Mit einer zweisprachigen Edition von Ludwig Heinrich Jakobs Preisschrift Quelles sont les institutions les plus propres a fonder la morale d'un peuple

by Sonja Asal