Scientia propter quid nobis
The Epistemic Independence of Metaphysics and Theology in the Quaestio de cognitione Dei attributed to Duns Scotus
by Wouter Goris
This study is part of a larger project on the primacy of adequacy in the philosophical thought of Duns Scotus. It offers, together with a critical edition, the first attempt at an overall interpretation of the Quaestio de cognitione Dei attributed to Duns Scotus – a text famous for its enhancement of Scotus’s conception of metaphysics with the systematic distinction between metaphysics as a science ‘in itself’ and ‘for us’. In line with the theory of science in the Lectura Parisiensis, in which Duns Scotus casts theology as a strictly demonstrative science in the present state (a scientia propter quid nobis), the Quaestio de cognitione Dei is seen to demand that the same be allowed for metaphysics as well – its conception of metaphysics as a scientia in se distinct from theology hence critically amends Scotus’s conception of metaphysics. This criticism not only shows that the Quaestio de cognitione Dei is wrongly attributed to Duns Scotus and is rather to be situated in the innerfranciscan debate on his Parisian theory of science in the second decade of the 14th century – in the direct environment of John of Reading, whose texts resonate in the Quaestio de cognitione Dei. This criticism also incites further investigation into the singular character of Scotus’s Parisian conception of science as well as a reconsideration of the traditional interpretation of his metaphysics, prey to the systematic inconsistency the Quaestio de cognitione Dei denounces.
- By (author) Wouter Goris
Other Titles in this Series
Die Verba Seniorum in der monastischen Welt Frankreichs im 12. Jahrhundert
Reformare oder meliorare?
Volume 21
Soteriologie in der spätmittelalterlichen Theologie
Soteriologie i.d. spätmittelalterlichen Theologie
Volume 23
Verus Filius Dei Incarnatus
The Christologies of Paulinus II of Aquileia, Benedict of Aniane, and Agobard of Lyon in the Context of the Felician Controversy
Volume 20
Der Lukaskommentar des Bonaventura von Bagnoregio als Handbuch der franziskanischen Spirituali
Volume 17
La reception de Duns Scot / Die Rezeption des Duns Scotus / Scotism through the Centuries
Proceedings of 'The Quadruple Congress' on John Duns Scotus. Part 4
Volume 6
In principio erat Verbum
Philosophy and Theology in the Commentaries on the Gospel of John (III-XIV Century)
Volume 11
Fides Virtus
The Virtue of Faith in the Context of the Theological Virtues from the 12th to the early 16th Centuries
Volume 12
Sacramentum Magnum
Die Ehe in der mittelalterlichen Theologie - Le mariage dans la theologie medievale - Marriage in Medieval Theology
Volume 15
Johannes Duns Scotus 1308-2008
Die philosophischen Perspektiven seines Werkes. Investigations into his Philosophy: Proceedings of 'The Quadruple Congress' on John Duns Scotus: Part 3
Volume 5
The Opera Theologica of John Duns Scotus
Proceedings of 'The Quadruple Congress' on John Duns Scotus
Volume 4
Dominican Theology at the Crossroads
A Critical Edition and Study of the Prologues to the Commentaries on Peter Lombard's Sentences by James of Metz and Hervaeus Natalis
Volume 2
Similar Books
A Late Antique Harrowing of Hell and Its Medieval Reception
Eusebius of Alexandria's Sermons 15 and 17 (CPG 5524; 5526) and their Latin Rewritings
Volume 99
Behind the Scenes of Medieval Roofs
An Overview of the Roofing Systems of Italian Churches
Volume 90
Drunk the Potion, No Whit Charmed
The Doctrine of Pure and Perfect Souls from Iamblichus to Damascius
Innovation and Medieval Communities
The Circulation of Ideas and Practices in and out of the Town (1200-1500)
Volume 63
Medieval Debates on Foreknowledge: Future Contingents, Prophecy, and Divination
Acts of the XXVII Annual Colloquium of the SIEPM, Trento 12-15 September 2023
Volume 31
Medieval Yeghegis, Armenia
History, Archaeology, Society. Local Multiplicities and Global Connections of a Rural Centre on the Silk Road(s)
Power and Women in Southeast and Central Europe in Late Medieval and Early Modern Period (1300-1600)
Volume 10
Tradition, Interpretation, and Change
Developments in the Liturgy of Medieval and Early Modern Ashkenaz
Women in Late Antiquity and the Early Middle Ages
Studies from Western Europe and North Africa
Volume 44
